Text Size:   A   A   A
Posted: Thursday, 25 June 2009 7:01AM

Will Joe Go?





yankees@wfan.com

Atlanta, GA (WFAN)  -- There are plenty of you out there who want to see the Yankees fire Joe Girardi. If the Yankees don't get on a big roll soon, that seat will get warm, especially if they lose the second round of the Subway Series this weekend.

This is not the Yankee way recently. The last time the Yankees made a mid-season managerial change was 1990. Bucky Dent out, Stump Merrill in. This team isn't nearly in that bad shape. But the expectations here are infinitely higher. If Joe Girardi doesn't make the playoffs this year he will be fired. So how long do the Yankees go before pulling the plug this time?

Hal Steinbrenner is not as volatile as his father or else we may have seen the volcano blow already. But a big vote of confidence came from Brian Cashman on Wednesday.

"I think Joe's done an exceptional job," Cashman said. "We're scuffling right now for three weeks, but he's not humped over, slumped over, he's not down and out and woe is me or depressed or on edge or tight. He's keeping his guys up, he's keeping them positive."

"He's doing everything he needs to do," Cashman concluded. This is the first manager Cashman chose in his time as GM and it was his first choice. He's not going to run him out of town because the Yankees forgot how to hit for a couple weeks.

Girardi has spent enough time in pinstripes to know job status is a talk-radio staple when the team is not playing well. So publicly at least, he is keeping a brave face.

"I know the drill here," Girardi said Wednesday. "You win or you go home. I understand that. I know what we have to do as a club. For me to spend time worrying about (my job) doesn't make a lot of sense. I worry about what we're doing on the field. The only thing that I can do is run the club the best way that I know how. Besides that, I don't make those decisions."

"I'm going to do everything in my power to win every game and that's all I can ever do," Girardi said.

If this season goes spiraling out of control between now and the All-Star break I would think some of those positions change. But for now, this is the way it is.

And while you continue to stick pins in your Girardi voodoo doll, try to come up with the guy you want to manage in his place. Fans of Donnie Baseball, you'll have to wait until the season is over. Same for fans of Bobby V.

So is there anyone in-house that can take over the managerial reigns? Here is your list to choose from:

Tony Pena, Yankees bench coach
Rob Thomson, Yankees 3rd base coach
Dave Miley, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre manager
Luis Sojo, A Tampa manager
Tino Martinez, Special Assistant to the GM
Stump Merrill, Special Assistant to the GM

Now let's think about this. Pena, Miley, and Stumper are the only ones on this list that have major league managing experience. No offense to any of them, but if you're going to be so drastic as to fire Joe Girardi are and of these guys making you feel like the season has been saved?

Thomson managed in the Yankee minor league system but is far removed from it. He has done an excellent job on the field with both Joe Torre and Joe Girardi, but there are those who feel his best work is in the front office.

Sojo hasn't managed above A-ball.

And before everyone starts getting these romantic delusions of seeing Tino Martinez take over as Yankees manager and lead them to the World Series, think again. Tino is a sharp guy and appears to enjoy his role as a voice in Cashman's ear, but he has zero managerial experience.

So what this comes down to is that unless the Yankees fail to pull out of this tailspin and are under .500 around the All-Star break, I don't think there will be anyone else in the manager's chair other than Girardi.

If you have visions of someone else riding to the rescue and leading this team all the way through the Canyon of Heroes victory parade, know this: only one Yankee team has ever changed managers in mid-season and won the World Series. And that took a furious comeback from 14 games out in 1978.

My guess is that Joe Girardi is your man in 2009. What happens in October will let us all know if he'll be back in 2010.

Thanks for reading. Send comments and questions to Yankees@wfan.com.

And remember to follow us at www.twitter.com/YankeesWFAN.

Filed Under :  Brian CashmanJoe GirardiYankees

Text Size:   A   A   A
06/25/2009 7:04AM
Will Joe Go?
Bring in Willie!!
06/25/2009 1:22PM
Manager
Here is my proposal: Tony Pena (the guy I wanted two years ago) takes over as manager and John Flaherty steps in as bench coach. I think their styles would mesh well, balance well and they would have a nice connection with the players.
06/25/2009 1:44PM
New Manager
Willie Randolph would be the perfect fit.
06/25/2009 2:42PM
Get the BUMS OUT
do get rid of Clueless Cashman..BRING BACK TORRIE
06/29/2009 9:58AM
Louuuu
Bring in Lou Piniella because he wont be resigned in Chicago.Regarding Willie being a perfect fit for the Yankee overbloated star studded staff?NOT!Willie can go manage the Royals or A's!
Title:
Comment:
Sweeny Says

Pleading the Fifth


Go back to 1997, the year after the Yankees won their first World Series under Joe Torre, and two of the most talked about players were a couple of kids who were less than two years removed from their big league debuts in Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera.

Healthy and Happy


Welcome to February. It may not feel like it outside, but spring is right around the corner. Pitchers and catchers are just two weeks away, and if that’s enough to warm you up right about now then try another pair of socks and some hot tea.

New York Welcomes Granderson


Curtis Granderson arrived in New York and his introductory press conference was the first at new Yankee Stadium, held in the spacious Legends Room. 

First Class


I can’t imagine I’ll ever have the privilege of covering a player like Hideki Matsui again. The word “unique” is thrown around too much, but this was indeed a unique experience, right from Day One.
Waldman's Way

Everyone Loves A Parade


The Perks of This Job!!!!!  The day started at 5AM. I had 3 alarm clocks and a coffee pot set, so I wouldn't oversleep. The call was for 7:30 at the Stadium to start getting on the 20 buses...

11 Down, None To Go!!


On December 26th, 1919, Harry Frazee sold Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees to finance the musical No, No, Nanette. Since that day, every time the Yankees win the World Series, it's because they have more money than anyone else...

A Tale of Two Cities


The Yankees traveling party left the Stadium this morning on 3 buses to go to Penn. Station, for the Amtrak Trek to Philadelphia. As the buses turned down 31st Street, we saw the crowds...

7 Down, 4 To Go


Back in 1986, a friend of mine, a 20 year season ticket holder at Yankee Stadium, said to me: "Who do I root for in this thing...it's THEM against THEM!" I guess Mets fans think the same thing right now?
Schmeelk in the Stands

Saving Our Pastime's Past


I’ve heard a bunch of different reactions to Mark McGwire’s “revelation” (seriously, if you were surprised by what he admitted, you need to stop taking your stupid pills). Some people were angry, others were disappointed, some were sick of steroids becoming a story again and other people actually felt sorry for the man since he kept crying.

Cashman's Folly


Someone is going to have to explain this one to me. Why wouldn’t the same reasons the Yankees had for not signing Hideki Matsui also apply to Nick Johnson? 

No Holiday Shopping


The Yankees should just close up shop, and pack it in until 2010. The only thing left to do is leave a contract offer on the table to Johnny Damon to think about over Christmas. Santa Steinbrenner should be fairly generous with a two year contract in the neighborhood of 20 million dollars. If another team finds him worthy of a three year deal, the Yankees should be content to watch him walk and

Expect Empty Stockings


I hate to be the Grinch that stole Christmas for all you Yankees fans out there, but this is going to be a quiet offseason. There isn't going to be a CC Sabathia. There isn't going to be a Mark Teixeira. There isn't even going to be an A.J. Burnett. 
Yankees Photos

Yankee Stadium Demolition Update - 2/2/2010


Photographs of the demolition of the old Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, February, 2, 2010.

Yankees' Series Trophy in Tokyo


Photos of the World Series trophy's first stop in what will be a six-day tour of Asia.
Yankees Blog Beat
Chad Jennings - LoHud Yankees Blog
Mark Feinsand - Blogging The Bombers
Tyler Kepner - Bats Blog
Pete Caldera - Pinstripe Posts
Marc Carig - Yankees Buzz
Bryan Hoch - Bombers Beat
Erik Boland - On The Yankees Beat
Joel Sherman - Yankees Blog